Sorry to take so long to get back to you. I really hate to say swap out the opamp, but it could be the problem. the 714 opamp is a tough little bugger that can take a lot of crap without being damaged. The thing is, it is a bit suspect that you aren't getting any signal from pin 6 of the opamp. I would also take a look at your soldering to your pots. Try jumpeing accross lug 2 and lug 3 of the VR1 and VR2. If you can suddenly get signal with the pedal on with one or both of the pots jumpered, there's your problem. If none of this fixes the problem, it could very well be the opamp. I'd at least reflow the solder joints to the opamp if you haven't already and see if this fixes it. However, if you do decide to remove the opamp, and that's strictly your decision, make sure you use the proper technique for desoldering it. Of course you may need to pruchase a desoldering pump and/or some desoldering braid (wick). Here goes:
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Here are a few tips on how to de-solder a component. I usually use my de-soldering iron to remove components. This method usually works like a charm but the dual sided BYOC PCBs with plated thru holes can present a problem. Especially when too much solder is used and there is as much solder on the component side of the board as there is on the solder side. In difficult cases like that I'll use an iron and a solder pump. You'll need either a set of helping hands to do this or have a friend close by that can lend a hand to hold the PCB steady as you remove the solder. Start by heating up the lead on the component side of the board. Try to do this as quickly as you can to keep excess heat transfer to the component and PCB to a minimum.
At the same time press the pump against the board so it forms a seal around the solder joint. This makes sure that the solder pump pulls the solder out of the hole instead of allowing air to leak around the tip of the pump.
Now let's say that you successfully removed the component but one of the holes is still filled with solder like it is here.
To remove the solder hold the iron against the hole and the pump over the hole on the other side. Heat up the solder and hit the button on the pump to suck out the excess solder. Again, you want to try to do this procedure quickly to keep excess heat transfer to the solder pad to a minimum.
Presto! You're done. Another way to clear the hole of solder is to heat it up and then quickly tap the board against your bench top. A third option would be to use a small hand drill (NOT a power drill) and drill bit to remove the solder.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
One last thing; when and if you do remove the opamp, while you're Radio Shack getting new one (for less than $1), go ahead and get an 8-pin DIP socket to put the opamp in (You can get tow of them for less than $1 as well). This way you've much less chance of thermally damaging the opamp while soldering. If you put a socket in, the opamp will never come into contact with any excess heat and be damaged
P.S. - Once again, muchos gracias to "Stephen's Tips For A Better Build" for info on desoldering. Once again, this information has proven to be invaluable